Phase-shift dynamics of sea urchin overgrazing on nutrified reefs
Shifts from productive kelp beds to impoverished sea urchin barrens occur globally and represent a wholesale change to the ecology of sub-tidal temperate reefs. Although the theory of shifts between alternative stable states is well advanced, there are few field studies detailing the dynamics of these kinds of transitions. In this study, sea urchin herbivory (a ‘top-down’ driver of ecosystems) was manipulated over 12 months to estimate (1) the sea urchin density at which kelp beds collapse to sea urchin barrens, and (2) the minimum sea urchin density required to maintain urchin barrens on experimental reefs in the urbanised Port Phillip Bay, Australia. In parallel, the role of one of the ‘bottom-up’ drivers of ecosystem structure was examined by (3) manipulating local nutrient levels and thus attempting to alter primary production on the experimental reefs. It was found that densities of 8 or more urchins m-2 (≥ 427 g m-2 biomass) lead to complete overgrazing of kelp beds while kelp bed recovery occurred when densities were reduced to ≤ 4 urchins m-2 (≤ 213 g m-2 biomass). This experiment provided further insight into the dynamics of transition between urchin barrens and kelp beds by exploring possible tipping-points which in this system can be found between 4 and 8 urchins m-2 (213 and 427 g m-2 respectively). Local enhancement of nutrient loading did not change the urchin density required for overgrazing or kelp bed recovery, as algal growth was not affected by nutrient enhancement.
Simple
Identification info
- Date (Creation)
- 2016-12-05
Principal investigator
Collaborator
Collaborator
- Purpose
- To examine the dynamics of ecosystem phase shifts between productive kelp beds and impoverished sea urchin barrens.
- Status
- Completed
Point of contact
Custodian
Custodian
- Temporal resolution
-
P0Y4M0DT0H0M0S
- Topic category
-
- Biota
Extent
Temporal extent
- Time period
- 2012-11-06 2013-12-02
- Maintenance and update frequency
- Not planned
Resource format
- Title
- Microsoft Excel
- Date
- Edition
- -
- Keywords (Theme)
-
- TEMPERATE ROCKY REEFS
- PORT PHILLIP BAY, AUSTRALIA
- REGIME-SHIFT
- KELP BED COLLAPSE
- KELP BED RECOVERY
- ARTIFICIAL REEFS
- NASA/GCMD Keywords, Version 8.5
-
- EARTH SCIENCE | BIOSPHERE | ECOSYSTEMS | MARINE ECOSYSTEMS
- EARTH SCIENCE | OCEANS | COASTAL PROCESSES | ROCKY COASTS
- EARTH SCIENCE | BIOLOGICAL CLASSIFICATION | ANIMALS/INVERTEBRATES | ECHINODERMS | SEA URCHINS
- EARTH SCIENCE | OCEANS | OCEAN CHEMISTRY | NUTRIENTS
- EARTH SCIENCE | BIOSPHERE | ECOSYSTEMS | MARINE ECOSYSTEMS | COASTAL | KELP FOREST
- EARTH SCIENCE | BIOLOGICAL CLASSIFICATION | PLANTS | MACROALGAE (SEAWEEDS)
- EARTH SCIENCE | BIOSPHERE | ECOLOGICAL DYNAMICS | SPECIES/POPULATION INTERACTIONS | GRAZING DYNAMICS/PLANT HERBIVORY
- Keywords (Taxon)
-
- HELIOCIDARIS ERYTHROGRAMMA
- ECKLONIA RADIATA
- Keywords (Discipline)
-
- Temperate Reef
- Keywords (Theme)
-
- sea urchin density per plot
- time past after start of experiment
- cover of all erect algae
- cover of turf-forming algae
- cover of all erect algae except Ecklonia radiata
- cover of all canopy-forming algae
- cover of all understorey-forming algae except encrusting algae
- cover of all canopy-forming algae except Ecklonia radiata
- cover of Ecklonia radiata
- count of juvenile Ecklonia radiata (stage 1: no lateral fronts developed yet) within the whole plot
- count of juvenile Ecklonia radiata (stage 2: small lateral fronds already developed) within the whole plot
- count of adult Ecklonia radiata (stage 3: fully developed individual) within the whole plot
- count of juvenile Ecklonia radiata within the whole plot
- count of all Ecklonia radiata within the plot regardless of stage
- count of adult Undaria pinnatifida
- count of juvenile Undaria pinnatifida within the whole plot
- count of all Undaria pinnatifida within the whole plot
- count of adult Sargassum vestitum within the whole plot
- count of juvenile Sargassum vestitum within the plot
- count of all Sargassum vestitum per plot
- count of all canopy-forming algae within the plot
- count of all canopy-forming algae within the plot except Ecklonia radiata stage 3 individuals
- count of all canopy-forming algae within the plot except Undaria pinnatifida
- cover of all macroalgae
- species richness
- shannon-index
- ammonia
- filterable reactive phosphorus
- nitrogen oxides
- ammonia and nitrogen oxides
- nitrogen and phosphorus
Resource constraints
- Classification
- Unclassified
Resource constraints
- Use limitation
- The data described in this record are the intellectual property of the University of Tasmania through the Institute for Marine and Antarctic Studies.
Resource constraints
- Linkage
-
http://i.creativecommons.org/l/by/4.0/88x31.png
License Graphic
- Title
- Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
- Website
-
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
License Text
- Other constraints
- The citation in a list of references is: citation author name/s (year metadata published), metadata title. Citation author organisation/s. File identifier and Data accessed at (add http link).
- Language
- English
- Character encoding
- UTF8
Content Information
- Content type
- Physical measurement
- Name
- sea urchin density per plot
- Name
- urchin_no
- Name
- density per plot
- Name
- time past after start of experiment
- Name
- month_elapsed
- Name
- months
- Name
- cover of all erect algae
- Name
- algae_cover
- Name
- percentage cover
- Name
- cover of turf-forming algae
- Name
- turf_cover
- Name
- percentage cover
- Name
- cover of all erect algae except Ecklonia radiata
- Name
- algae_minus_ecklonia_cover
- Name
- percentage cover
- Name
- cover of all canopy-forming algae
- Name
- canopy_cover
- Name
- percentage cover
- Name
- cover of all understorey-forming algae except encrusting algae
- Name
- understorey_minus_encrusting_cover
- Name
- percentage cover
- Name
- cover of all canopy-forming algae except Ecklonia radiata
- Name
- canopy_minus_ecklonia_cover
- Name
- percentage cover
- Name
- cover of Ecklonia radiata
- Name
- eck_rad_cover
- Name
- percentage cover
- Name
- count of juvenile Ecklonia radiata (stage 1: no lateral fronts developed yet) within the whole plot
- Name
- tot_eck_stage_1_count
- Name
- stipe count per plot
- Name
- count of juvenile Ecklonia radiata (stage 2: small lateral fronds already developed) within the whole plot
- Name
- tot_eck_stage_2_count
- Name
- stipe count per plot
- Name
- count of adult Ecklonia radiata (stage 3: fully developed individual) within the whole plot
- Name
- tot_eck_stage_3_count
- Name
- stipe count per plot
- Name
- count of juvenile Ecklonia radiata within the whole plot
- Name
- tot_eck_1_2_count
- Name
- stipe count per plot
- Name
- count of all Ecklonia radiata within the plot regardless of stage
- Name
- tot_eck_count
- Name
- stipe count per plot
- Name
- count of adult Undaria pinnatifida
- Name
- tot_und_pin_ad_count
- Name
- stipe count per plot
- Name
- count of juvenile Undaria pinnatifida within the whole plot
- Name
- tot_und_pin_juv_count
- Name
- stipe count per plot
- Name
- count of all Undaria pinnatifida within the whole plot
- Name
- tot_und_pin_count
- Name
- stipe count per plot
- Name
- count of adult Sargassum vestitum within the whole plot
- Name
- tot_sar_ves_ad_count
- Name
- stipe count per plot
- Name
- count of juvenile Sargassum vestitum within the plot
- Name
- tot_sar_ves_ju_count
- Name
- stipe count per plot
- Name
- count of all Sargassum vestitum per plot
- Name
- tot_sarg_ves_count
- Name
- stipe count per plot
- Name
- count of all canopy-forming algae within the plot
- Name
- tot_canopy_count
- Name
- stipe count per plot
- Name
- count of all canopy-forming algae within the plot except Ecklonia radiata stage 3 individuals
- Name
- tot_canopy_no_st3
- Name
- stipe count per plot
- Name
- count of all canopy-forming algae within the plot except Undaria pinnatifida
- Name
- tot_canopy_minus_und_count
- Name
- stipe count per plot
- Name
- cover of all macroalgae
- Name
- tot_algal_cover
- Name
- percentage cover
- Name
- species richness
- Name
- sp
- Name
- species per plot
- Name
- shannon-index
- Name
- H
- Name
- species per plot
- Name
- ammonia
- Name
- NH3
- Name
- micromole per liter
- Name
- filterable reactive phosphorus
- Name
- FRP
- Identifier
- http://vocab.nerc.ac.uk/collection/P06/current/UPOX
- Name
- Micromoles per litre
- Name
- nitrogen oxides
- Name
- Nox
- Identifier
- http://vocab.nerc.ac.uk/collection/P06/current/UPOX
- Name
- Micromoles per litre
- Name
- ammonia and nitrogen oxides
- Name
- tot_N
- Identifier
- http://vocab.nerc.ac.uk/collection/P06/current/UPOX
- Name
- Micromoles per litre
- Name
- nitrogen and phosphorus
- Name
- tot
- Identifier
- http://vocab.nerc.ac.uk/collection/P06/current/UPOX
- Name
- Micromoles per litre
Identifier
- Code
- Abundance of biota
Identifier
Distribution Information
- Distribution format
-
- .xlsx
- OnLine resource
- DATA - community responses to sea urchin herbivory and nutrient enrichment (.xlsx) [direct download]
- OnLine resource
-
imas:ARC_NKriegisch_Phaseshift_urchin_grazing_nutrified_reefs_MAP
MAP - General study area
Resource lineage
- Statement
- Small boulders and cobbles (0.20 - 0.50 m diam.) were sourced from the adjacent rocky reef and constructed into 28 patch reefs (each ~ 0.85 m2 planar area) on the sand patch. Reefs were separated by at least 5 m from each other and from the surrounding natural reef. The 28 boulder reefs were assigned randomly to a total of 4 treatments representing combinations of ‘reef ecosystem state’ (kelp beds vs urchin barrens) and ‘nutrient’ conditions (ambient vs enhanced), and within each treatment the 7 replicate reefs supported urchins at densities of 0, 4, 8, 12, 15, 20 and 24 urchins m-2. Three adult E. radiata individuals were transplanted to each appropriate patch reef to simulate the ‘kelp bed state’, providing a canopy cover of ~ 50% within the internal 0.25 m2 of each patch reef. 200 g of slow release fertiliser (Osmocote® Pro 3-4 M, 17N:4.8P:8.3K) was used to enhance nutrients on individual patch reefs. After randomly assigning the 4 different ‘reef state’ and ‘nutrient condition’ treatments to the experimental patch reefs, each of the 7 replicate patch-reefs within each treatment received (at random) one of 7 different urchin densities (0, 4, 8, 12, 15, 20 and 24 urchins m-2). Reefs were then checked every 3 weeks for the 12 months of the experiment to ensure urchin densities were maintained at their designated level. The amount of erect macroalgae on each reef was assessed every 3 months. Assessments were undertaken on SCUBA with in situ estimates of percentage cover of canopy-formers and understorey. Percentage cover assessments were performed using the point-intercept method (a 50 by 50 cm quadrat with 49 regularly spaced points defined by intersecting string lines, and an additional random point within the quadrat assigned in advance). Stipe counts were used to enumerate the abundance of canopy-forming brown algae (E. radiata, S. vestitum, and the introduced ephemeral Japanese kelp U. pinnatifida), and on the final assessment the total number of macroalgal species on each patch reef was counted.
- Hierarchy level
- Dataset
- Hierarchy level
- Dataset
Platform
Identifier
- Code
- diver
- Hierarchy level
- Dataset
Platform
Identifier
- Code
- research vessel
Metadata
- Metadata identifier
- 21245d18-7a4f-4e25-9b98-ae90ae92748b
- Language
- English
- Character encoding
- UTF8
Point of contact
Type of resource
- Resource scope
- Dataset
- Metadata linkage
-
https://metadata.imas.utas.edu.au/geonetwork/srv/eng/catalog.search#/metadata/21245d18-7a4f-4e25-9b98-ae90ae92748b
Point of truth URL of this metadata record
- Date info (Creation)
- 2020-08-14T12:02:12
- Date info (Revision)
- 2020-08-14T12:02:12
Metadata standard
- Title
- ISO 19115-3:2018